Sorry ! I'm sure that eBay one will be OK, I was just suggesting to double-check the output polarity.
These flat-aluminium-plate rectifiers are built with multiple press-fit small diodes, two or three or more taking the place of each of the four diodes that you need to make a full-wave bridge rectifier. These small diodes share the current, rather than using four single massive stud-mounted diodes. The press-fit diodes aren't easy to source, and replacements really should be matched to the originals, so that the total current is shared equally.
The rectifier would have to be dismantled, to find out how many of the small diodes have failed, and what type they are, then check if they are available. If you want to send the rectifier to me, I could do this for you...