The motors look slightly different, but are they the same make?, do they have a rating plate that is readable as it could tell you what size capacitors it requires. Do you have a sparky mate that has a capacitor tester to test them for you, otherwise you could go to your local motor re-winds place and ask them to give them a once over, they would be able to tell you what caps should be on them more than likely.
When you run the one that works , when it gets up to cut out pressure does the switch hiss when it cuts out, as its then that the pressure switch is supposed to unload the pressure from the compressor discharge pipe.
When you run the one that works , when it gets up to cut out pressure does the switch hiss when it cuts out, as its then that the pressure switch is supposed to unload the pressure from the compressor discharge pipe.